Beating The Tide: Stock Picks That Outperform

Beating The Tide: Stock Picks That Outperform

After Two AI Picks Hit +1,000%, Here's Where I'm Recycling The Capital

A regulatory regime change, a pending European JV, +65% upside against a risk-reward 1 to 2.9. Buy.

George Atuan, CFA's avatar
George Atuan, CFA
May 20, 2026
∙ Paid

Note:

Since my trade alert on Monday, the shares are down to $59, so the upside is now 74% with a risk-reward of 1 to 3.2. Even better!


Evil Kermit Meme | Buy something respectable; There's money in what restaurants throw out | image tagged in memes,evil kermit | made w/ Imgflip meme maker

My top three positions that have 5x to 8x1 are AI-related holdings, POWL and STRL, crossed +1,000% last week.

Beating The Tide portfolio tracker showing POWL HOLD recommendation +1,096% total return and STRL HOLD recommendation +1,055.7% total return — the two AI-related holdings that crossed +1,000% this week. Source: BTT portfolio tracker also celestica

That kind of move is the privilege of buying right and sitting still, but it also concentrates the portfolio in one theme. Almost a fifth of the portfolio (6 companies out of a total of 31) are related to the AI-theme. All those positions have appreciated considerably. The one with the smallest gain is MU, which has gained 106% from the cost basis…

Micron, MU cost basis and market value in Beating the Tide portfolio showing a 106%

… or 136% since I recommended it the first time.

Beating The Tide track record of stock picks showing micron, MU, up 136% since it was picked

So while 19% of the positions are in the AI-theme on a count basis, 38.3% of the market value of the portfolio is in the theme.

So I’ve been hunting in sectors I actually understand, away from the AI complex. Energy first. In November, I flagged in the Weekly 58 that energy was the sector to watch on a 12-month view.

Weekly #58: The S&P 500 Isn’t as Expensive as You Think… and One Sector Is Still Cheap

Weekly #58: The S&P 500 Isn’t as Expensive as You Think… and One Sector Is Still Cheap

George Atuan, CFA
·
November 30, 2025
Read full story

In December, I followed with my first energy pick…

Trade alert: The Market Is Ignoring This Corner of Energy

Trade alert: The Market Is Ignoring This Corner of Energy

George Atuan, CFA
·
December 16, 2025
Read full story

… and in March, I added a second energy name in MENA oilfield services.

Deep Dive: The Eagle in the Desert: My Highest-Conviction Energy Buy of 2026

Deep Dive: The Eagle in the Desert: My Highest-Conviction Energy Buy of 2026

George Atuan, CFA
·
Mar 20
Read full story

Utilities second. In February I picked up a utility name that slipped through my fingers in 2024 when valuation finally became sensible.

A Boring LATAM Utility With a Not-So-Boring +40% Upside

A Boring LATAM Utility With a Not-So-Boring +40% Upside

George Atuan, CFA
·
Jan 21
Read full story

Defence third. My April defence pick sits on the +13.4% FY2026 budget signal and a multi-year spend cycle.

The Next Boom No One Wants to Talk About Is Already Underway

The Next Boom No One Wants to Talk About Is Already Underway

George Atuan, CFA
·
Apr 15
Read full story

So far, 3 out of my 4 picks show a positive return. Defence shows a loss, but it hasn’t been more than a month yet.

Beating The Tide monthly picks track record showing consistent positive returns

So which space will be the fourth???

a thinking man wondering what is the forth sector

Food is the fourth, and the logic looks like defence: regulatory tailwinds doing the work, multiples compressed, and the operating story turning before the multiple does. Of every food name I’ve looked at over the past month, this one is the one I keep coming back to.

Why Food, Why Now

I’ve spent the past quarter looking at every credible food name with a circular-economy or biofuel angle. Adecoagro. Bunge. ADM. Bachoco. Pilgrim’s Pride (which I just exited).

The Halal Chicken Plant That Taught Me To Close Pilgrim's Pride

The Halal Chicken Plant That Taught Me To Close Pilgrim's Pride

George Atuan, CFA
·
Apr 23
Read full story

Of all of them, this one has the most asymmetric setup right now because three things are converging at the same time.

  1. A federal regulator finalized the largest renewable fuel mandate in the program’s history.

  2. A pending European joint venture gives the high-margin specialty arm a 12-16x EBITDA re-rating catalyst inside the next 12 months.

  3. And the operations team has spent two years cleaning up two big acquisitions, with the result showing up cleanly in Q1 2026’s gross margin print.

Each of those would be useful on its own. Together, they’re a regime change.

The market hasn’t repriced for this. The stock trades at 14.5x EV/EBITDA versus a 5-year average of 13.5x, slightly above on the surface, but the trough year compresses EBITDA artificially.

DAR EV/EBITDA chart 2022 to May 2026 showing the multiple compressing from ~25x peak in early 2022 down to a sub-$10x trough through 2024-2025 and now recovering to 14.73x as of May 6 2026. Source: Seeking Alpha / YCharts.

On the DCF-implied EV/EBITDA of 20.6x, the entry today is 40% below fair value. P/B at 2.2x versus the 5-year average of 2.1x looks slightly expensive only because book value is depressed.

Darling Ingredients (DAR) Price-to-Book ratio chart 2022 to May 2026 showing the multiple compressing from ~3.6x peak in early 2022 down to ~1.2x trough through 2024-2025 and now recovering to 2.086x as of May 7 2026, just below the 5-year average of 2.246x. Source: Seeking Alpha / YCharts.

This company is the unglamorous opposite of an AI compute story. The company picks up dead animals, used fryer oil, and slaughterhouse byproducts from hundreds of thousands of collection points and turns them into proteins, fats, collagen, gelatin, and renewable diesel feedstock. Every part of the supply chain is regulated. Every cent of the margin depends on commodity pricing. The stock has been cut in half from its 2022 highs and is one of the most hated names in consumer staples. It’s exactly the kind of business I want to own when the AI frenzy needs a counterweight.


Table of Contents:

  • TLDR

  • How Does The Company Rank?

  • How Does It Actually Make Money

  • The Pricing Dynamics That Run This Business

  • The Long-Form Thesis

  • Valuation

  • Steel-Manning The Bear

  • Variant Perception

  • Verdict


This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2026 Beating The Tide · Publisher Privacy ∙ Publisher Terms
Substack · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture