Beating The Tide: Stock Picks That Outperform

Beating The Tide: Stock Picks That Outperform

Trade alert: The Market Is Ignoring This Corner of Energy

A cash-gushing oil & gas business trading at a discount to peers, assets, and fundamentals at a time when the energy sector is still deeply unloved.

George Atuan, CFA's avatar
George Atuan, CFA
Dec 16, 2025
∙ Paid
Illustration meme of a well-dressed capybara holding a wine glass with text about numbers making sense but being ignored at cocktail parties, symbolizing an overlooked energy stock in the investment thesis deep dive.

I recently noted that energy was the one S&P 500 sector still trading below its 10-year average valuation, making it a glaring outlier in a market otherwise driven up by tech mega-caps.

Weekly #58: The S&P 500 Isn’t as Expensive as You Think… and One Sector Is Still Cheap

Weekly #58: The S&P 500 Isn’t as Expensive as You Think… and One Sector Is Still Cheap

George Atuan, CFA
·
Nov 30
Read full story

In that weekly piece, I confessed that I held zero oil & gas stocks at the time, a gap I intended to fill. Many readers responded with suggestions (thank you all and a special thanks to JB for the extensive list!), helping me assemble a shortlist of energy candidates: major refiners like VLO and PSX, a niche specialty player (CLMT), a large integrated refiner MPC, and PARR, a smaller refining underdog. After reviewing them, one stood out as the best fit for our portfolio’s December pick.

To see which stock made the cut and read the full deep dive, you can upgrade to paid. You will also get access to all past deep dives, my full portfolio, and real-time trade alerts.

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Beating The Tide · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture